Written by Amanda Rodriguez.
There are soooo many superheroes out there. These gents get top billing in comics, movies, and TV shows while their superheroine counterparts tend to get the shaft, existing in unwarranted obscurity or playing second fiddle to a male lead. Do these super-dudes deserve all this limelight? Is there something inherently male about them that makes them special, or would some of these superheroes be just as good, if not better off, as women? Many superheroes have been re-imagined as superheroines (Batwoman, Supergirl, Spidergirl, etc.), and some of them should be re-cast as superheroines. Here’s my Top 10 list of super-dudes who are or should be super-ladies.
1. Thor from The Avengers
Re-casting Thor as a woman is a done deal. Marvel has taken one of its oldest and most popular heroes who’s appeared in a slew of films and announced that henceforth Thor will be a female god. She won’t exist alongside the original Thor, as so many female re-imaginings of superheroes do (even some on this list), but, instead she will supplant her unworthy predecessor, taking his place as God of Thunder in Asgard, wielding his magic hammer and his titan strength.
Despite my love of the Norse mythology from which the comic hero is derived, I’ve never much cared for Thor. He often struck me as a dumb, self-important brute of a man. Now, though, I’m curious to see how Marvel handles the transition (though I’d love if Thor was trans*, pun not intended), and I’m excited to see how a female all-powerful god handles herself.
2. Venus from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Venus de Milo is a somewhat obscure addition to the TMNT canon of humanoid, intelligent mutated turtles. Unlike the male turtles, she’s named after a work of art rather than an artist, and I’m definitely reading some lack of female subjectivity into that choice. In the short-lived live action series Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation, Venus reunites with her brothers, and while she doesn’t know martial arts like her brothers, she uses magic instead.
While it’s pretty cool that this brief and obscure series added a female turtle, it begs the question, “Why wasn’t one of the four original turtles a girl?” While apparently comic writers were mandated to not include a female turtle, for this reviewer who was once so into the Turtles that she drew their portraits and hung them over her bed, there’s really no satisfying answer. Now that the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have made another comeback and are back on the big screen, it’s time to bring back Venus…only please make sure she can kick some ass with a weapon, too, and not just float around some weird balls David-Bowie Labyrinth-style.
3. Spawn
Todd McFarlane’s popular comic Spawn features Al Simmons, a military man of questionable morals, who dies and is brought back as a supremely powerful demonic figure to collect souls for hell. Like all good anti-heroes, Spawn refuses to play nice for heaven or hell. The comic is lush, dark, and gritty, featuring a Black hero. Spawn was turned into a moderately successful cartoon series and a craptastic film series.
Though the comics have briefly featured women having or taking over Spawn’s powers and the dreaded angel Angela has had her own miniseries, a female Spawn has never been given a real chance as a lead. We also need more superheroines of color, and since the original Spawn is a Black man, there’s no reason why a female version couldn’t also be Black. Frankly, I’d love to see a strong, dark, morally complex woman deal with being a putrefying corpse reanimated to perform an eternal mission in which she doesn’t believe. Now that’s a rich role that a woman could really dig into.
4. The Question from 52
The original DC comic book version of The Question is the male Vic Sage. Though The Question doesn’t have any super powers to speak of, he wears a faceless mask that obscures his features. In the series 52, a terminally ill Vic trains Renee Montoya, a lesbian ex-Gotham City cop and on-and-off love interest of Batwoman, to be his replacement. Thus, The Question was born anew.
I love Renee Montoya because she’s an exceedingly rare Latina superheroine, she’s also an exceedingly rare lesbian superheroine, she doesn’t have any superpowers or a trust fund but still manages to fight the good fight, and she questions everything. She’s an interesting, emotionally messed up character who figures out answers for herself, lives by her own moral compass, and every once in a while, gets to save the girl (even if that girl is a totally hardcore Batwoman). Dear Montoya, you are so much win.
5. She-Hulk
Jennifer Walters is the cousin of rogue scientist Bruce Banner a.k.a the Hulk. After a blood transfusion from him, She-Hulk is born. A star lawyer who defends the rights of the disenfranchised and an Avenger, She-Hulk also maintains much of her personality when she transforms into her green-skinned form. Often considered the strongest woman in the Marvel universe, She-Hulk is incredibly intelligent and skilled at combat. Despite (or perhaps because of) her extremely tall, muscled, green body, She-Hulk is a huge sex symbol in the comics industry.
Like her male counterpart the Hulk, She-Hulk also contends with an antihero version of her powers in the form of Red She-Hulk (Banner love interest Betty Ross who’s had a couple of cameos over the years). Both of these women are differing, but intriguing representations and applications of female power and psychology, often becoming more confident and/or aggressive in their Hulk-ified bodies, choosing when to transform, and internalizing positive or negative feelings of self-worth based on their bodies. Now if we can just get one or both of these badass babes a movie…
6. Captain Marvel
Though Carol Danvers has been known by many different names over her 46 years in comics (Ms. Marvel, Binary, and Warbird), I like her best as Captain Marvel. Though Danvers derives her latest title directly from the male Captain Marvel, the name itself has a long history with both men and women indiscriminately donning it over time. I also prefer the current Captain Marvel because she’s now penned by female comic writer Kelly Sue DeConnick, and her costume has been altered to be far less revealing and far more practical than Danvers ever enjoyed before.
Danvers has the powers of the Captain Marvel hero (and, at times, antihero) line with superhuman strength, endurance, speed, and flight. Over the years, she’s also developed abilities of her own, including light speed travel, shooting energy beams from her hands, and absorption of energy to boost her own powers. Along with that, she also has combat, flight, as well as tactical and strategic skills from her air force days. As an Avenger and a member of Guardians of the Galaxy, it’s a possibility that she’ll appear in one or both of those franchises. Lately, rumors also speculate that Katee Sackhoff will aptly play the title role in a Captain Marvel an upcoming film. Considering studios’ extreme and groundless resistance to making a woman-fronted superhero flick, it’s doubtful, but a girl can dream.
7. Darth Talon
My first encounter with Darth Talon of the Star Wars universe was at Dragon-con in Atlanta (yes, I’m that nerdy) where a very dedicated woman cosplayed the hell out of that dark side Twi’lek, and I lost my shit at Talon’s sheer awesomeness. With her red skin, Sith tattoos, yellow eyes, and dedication to the dark side, Darth Talon is basically a female version of Darth Maul, the primary antagonist in Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace.
Though Darth Talon is the villainess female equivalent of a villain (and not a superheroine at all really), she deserves a spot on this list because she has the potential to be an iconic female version of a male figure. With her strength, cunning, and loyalty to the dark side, I’ve got my fingers crossed that she’s one of the characters we’ll be seeing in the upcoming Star Wars: Episode VII.
8. Black Panther
The male Black Panther (T’Challa) was the first ever Black superhero to hit mainstream comics. The lover and sometime husband of X-Men‘s Storm, Black Panther is the chief of a powerful nation in Africa known as Wakanda. To protect his people and lands from inevitable exploitation for their valuable natural resources, Black Panther hides his country from the outside world. He is a much needed Black African hero who, in a sense, rewrites the colonial history of the African continent by guarding his country from very real greed and imperialistic forces. When T’Challa nearly dies and loses his powers, his sister Shuri takes on the Black Panther mantle.
Like her brother, Shuri leads her country and possesses superhuman strength and agility along with a protective suit constructed from Wakanda’s precious, coveted mineral vibranium. Being the Black Panter, imbued with such great power and responsibility, changes Shuri. She learns the value of humility and self-sacrifice while becoming a respected diplomat and a fierce leader who makes it abundantly clear that her country is not to be fucked with. We need more representation for badass Black superheroines like Black Panther who can help us re-imagine and therefore empower a continent that has been brutally and tirelessly exploited for hundreds of years.
9. Hellgirl
There is no Hellgirl female version of Hellboy, the crusty but loveable demon beautifully rendered by creator Mike Mignola. There’s nothing inherently gendered about Hellboy’s red tail, sawed off horns, giant stone fist, and propensity for cigars. There’s nothing inherently male about his dark origins and his desire to overcome them to do good in the world.
In fact, I’d argue that a physically and emotionally rough-around-the-edges superheroine is just what we need. Enough of these drawings of women with stereotypically unrealistic bodies and their giant, barely covered breasts. Give us a superheroine who has to shave her horns instead of her legs, a woman who, like Hellboy, hides a gentle heart behind a jagged exterior, who struggles with depression and low self-worth but still manages to save the world.
10. Link from The Legend of Zelda
Lastly and dearest to my heart, we’ve got the hero of Hyrule, Link, who is already pretty androgynous with his gender neutral name, dress-like tunic, long blonde hair, lithe build, and elven ears. He could easily be re-cast as a female character, if not removed completely, giving Zelda the agency to save Hyrule. Don’t get me wrong, I love me some Link, but is there a reason Zelda even needs him to save the day in a video game that’s named after her?
Zelda, herself, is wise, magical, and skilled in combat. She even cross-dresses as Sheik, a figure who guides Link to important knowledge he needs to complete his quest. Why can’t Zelda be the Heroine of Time, supplanting Link as her savior? And while we’re at it, why the hell haven’t we had a movie version of The Legend of Zelda yet? Other than that they’d probably butcher it, I can’t think of a single good reason.
Though some argue the valid perspective that turning existing male superheroes into superheroines is lazy or doesn’t give female heroes their own identities, I mostly think that turning popular iconic male figures into women shows that gender isn’t that important when it comes to being powerful, capable, and a force for good in the world. In a time when female representation is often limited to sexual objectification, re-presenting male heroes as heroines in particular shows young girls that gender roles are arbitrary and that women can accomplish the same goals and be just as amazing as men. We need that right now.
Read also:
Top 10 Superheroines Who Deserve Their Own Movies
Top 10 Superheroine Movies that Need a Reboot
Top 10 Villainesses Who Deserve Their Own Movies
Bitch Flicks writer and editor Amanda Rodriguez is an environmental activist living in Asheville, North Carolina. She holds a BA from Antioch College in Yellow Springs, Ohio and an MFA in fiction writing from Queens University in Charlotte, NC. Her short story “The Woman Who Fell in Love with a Mermaid” was published in Germ Magazine. She writes all about food and drinking games on her blog Booze and Baking. Fun fact: while living in Kyoto, Japan, her house was attacked by monkeys.
A character being female doesn’t make them better than their male counterparts and vice versa. Gender has nothing to do with what makes a character good. It’s the writing and stories that do it.
You’d think that was true, but where are all the female stories then? We need to show the world that not only are women and superheroines a viable market for our cash-obsessed media, but their stories are every bit as compelling as their male counterparts. Showing that male heroes turned into female heroes are successful is a great way to break that gender divide.
Some how this doesn’t make a lot of sense, maybe because of the deceiving title which wound need to be “heroes that would be better as female”.
Now some I haven’t read, and some you just picked fanart and decided it would be better (like Hellboy). Maybe Thor would be better as a woman, if the story is well done, I really want to read the story because it seems interesting, Captain Marvel I think is cool, but must of the others I don’t really care. Now. regarding Hulk. The way they created She Hulk is cool, but it missess the point of Hulk, which is pure force and how that overcome intelligence, and ultimately the creation of a human good, and She Hulk is way away from that so in that one in particular I think you are really wrong.
Where are the female stories?… well, I’d say there are just as many good female-led stories published as good male-led stories. But there are so many more mediocre or even *terrible* male-led stories….
One of the problems seems to be that publishers and producers will publish/produce any old garbage with a male hero (examples include “Superman Returns”), but refuse to take any chances with female heroines. Out of pure, outright sexism, I presume.
Several of Marvel’s most famous (non-X-men) female characters derive from Stan Lee, in the 1970s, worrying that he was going to lose the trademarks to the female versions of various trademarked male characters. As a result, She-Hulk, Spiderwoman, and IIRC Ms. Marvel were all rushed into print. Since there was a corporate mandate to keep them in print to maintain the trademark, they kept working at them until they started to get good stories (which took a while in each case).
By contrast, the plug has often been pulled on female-lead comic books before they have had time to find their footing. While male-lead comics usually get a much longer grace period. There’s sexism for you.
Why “Venus”? The other turtles are named after artists, not subjects.
How about keeping with the theme by naming her Artemesia, instead?
“Enough of these drawings of women with stereotypically unrealistic bodies and their giant, barely covered breasts.”
And yet, the first pic has a midriff-bared CA, Thor in a loincloth, Hulk in a crop top and cutoffs, and Loki in a pushup bra. maybe half of the pics have women smaller than a DD cup, Hellgirl’s jeans are held up by a wish, and Darth Talon will flash everyone if she sneezes hard. And there’s a turtle…with boob plates? Why bother talking about how we need to ditch the stereotype, and then use the stereotype as the illustrations?
I totally agree. Like captain america? Obviously you have scratches on your stomach because YOU’RE NOT COVERED! But some of them make sense. Like Loki. Loki is a queen more or less so obviously she is going to try to be sexy because gods. Thor kind of makes sense because that’s kind of what warriors wore I guess. And the male Hulk’s shirt comes all the way off, so, technically, especially since the She-Hulk has boobs, she should also be shirtless, but I think we are all grateful for that not happening…. But honestly, why in the name of HELL is Hellgirl not wearing suspenders? That’s not how hips work! Darth. Dahling, no. I know your a space warrior person thing, and that is what they wear, but have you ever heard of STRAPS? Because I’m pretty sure the double-sided tape supply on the Death Star is dwindling. I mean, I guess the boob plates kind of make sense because she’s genetically mutated…? Because, it’s better than making her wear a shirt and be different than the boys…. oh, sure.
Sadly, if you source images from the internet and don’t create them yourself (I’m not an artist or graphic designer), then there are few, if any, images that don’t sexually exploit female superheroes.
She hulk definitely needs a movie, given her mix of actual lawyer day job and heroic whenever-it-needs-to-happen job, she’s got a lot more opportunity for interesting stories than most other heroes.
Along the topic of Zelda, did you see Aaron Diaz’s version of a gender-re-focused Hyule game? http://dresdencodak.tumblr.com/post/47724463171/inspired-by-anita-sarkeesians-video-game-tropes
i agree with you why do they make all these heroes based on the male gender what happened to us women we too deserve to be amongst the important people in the society……but one more thing i have to agree with charlene hamilton why are women so acknowledged into going around half naked which is not right we should be able to hold up our dignity as a proud creation cause we are a very important part of the success of this world