Stop Leaving Money on the Table: Change Who’s Sitting At It

Men are spoilt for choice; women are starved. Targeting women is like selling ice to a Bedouin, during a heatwave, in a particularly bad year for the ice harvest. Quality content for women has scarcity value.

bridesmaids


This is a guest post by Zoe Samuel.


We live in the age of data, on the personal and demographic scale.  Research is changing our understanding of who consumes content, how they do so, and what value they offer advertisers and partners.  We know now that there is a group of people who control 70 percent of domestic consumer spending; spend more time  on social media; buy 52 percent of  movie  tickets and 68 percent of theater tickets; and watch more TV than any other group.  This demographic is vast: 51 percent of the population.

The group in question is, of course, women.  The market opportunity represented by this demographic, as creators and consumers, remains the greatest source of untapped or under-exploited revenue in entertainment.

rs_1024x759-140826073311-1024.Ben-Affleck-Gone-Girl-JR-82614

The amount of competition for the attention of women, when compared to the amount of competition for men, is still currently very low.  This demo is horribly under-served, both in the quality and the quantity of content available to it.  As far as quality, when it looks at a screen, it is perhaps surprising that it doesn’t have a rage fit and throw things.  If it were to buy into how it is portrayed on the screen, it would see itself as few in number; vapid and narcissistic; over-sexualized but rarely possessing any actual desire of its own; an unfunny mirror for other people’s comedy; limited in age range; almost entirely devoid of agency (bearing in mind that feistiness is not a substitute); and just plain stupid.  Even given all of this, it is still the bedrock of the market.

bc58c742bdc0203eb9ed59c83e20b9ef

Regarding quantity, the mere fact that content is predominantly still aimed at men is proof in and of itself that instinct, not data, is guiding decision-making here, and that that instinct is about 40 years out of date.  Men are spoilt for choice; women are starved.  Targeting women is like selling ice to a Bedouin, during a heatwave, in a particularly bad year for the ice harvest.  Quality content for women has scarcity value.

There is a huge opportunity here.  If women buy even when they are not targeted, they buy many times over when they are.  This demo rapaciously consumes any content that speaks to it as it is, and as it wishes it could be: three-dimensional, flawed, sexual, old, young, eccentric, powerful, intelligent, funny, varied.  Whenever it is treated with this sort of basic respect, it shows up in vast numbers: Bridesmaids, The Heat, The Hunger Games, The Fault In Our Stars, Gone Girl, Divergent, Frozen, Cinderella … these are not aberrations.  This is not a niche.  This is the invisible hand at work, throwing huge piles of money at people who are paying attention.

copy-burn-the-fault-in-our-stars-dvd

This is a demo worth aiming content at, and that requires creators who get their audience’s needs and wants.  Selling to a demographic you don’t understand is essentially impossible.  And the only way to understand women is – just as with men – either to listen to them, or be them.  Clearly men who listen to women can write for women: the songs that made Frozen a hit were written by a married couple, Bobby Lopez and Kristen Andersen-Lopez.  Joss Whedon has impeccable credentials when it comes to appealing to women.  Shakespeare was doing it centuries ago.  It works in reverse, too: Kathryn Bigelow has made a stellar career out of making very dudely movies watched mostly by dudes.

2.168183

That said, there are certainly correlations showing that women on the team result in women on the screen, and we’ve already established that women on the screen equals bringing in the green.  The same way that women in the boardroom correlate with higher profits, women on the creative team are good for the bottom line.  In the words of Sheryl Sandberg, “If men want to make their work teams successful, one of the best steps they can take is to bring on more women.”  Shows with a more mixed writers’ room enjoy higher audience retention and are more likely to get a second season.  Just as people typically hire in their own image, they tend to create in their own image, which means a team with a bigger variety of voices is more likely to competently portray a variety of characters.  It’s not because the creators are better, but that they are unlike each other.  It’s Darwinian; their strength comes from their variety.  (It is probably–and it would be great to see data on this–also because the sort of company that hires and promotes against stereotype when it comes to women is self-evidently adaptable and creative, and is thus more robust in other ways, such as hiring the highest quality men.)

the-heat-5

Women, as an audience, represent more value for less effort.  Data is everything, and the data doesn’t lie.  What’s happening to the media marketplace is not a trend.  It’s not even a movement.  It’s the economy, stupid, and it’s not going away.

In short, it doesn’t matter how you feel about women qua women.  What matters is how you feel about money, qua money, in your wallet, paying your bills, sitting on your driveway in the form of a really expensive car (that, statistically speaking, your wife bought).  The last person into any market has the toughest time.  The wise course is to get in now before all the best seats are taken, and then fill a bunch of them with women.  Alternatively, leave all that money on the table, and wait for someone else to come along and take it.

 


Zoe Samuel is a British-born writer who writes for stage and screen from her home on a plane between New York and London. She’s also VP of Theater for Concert Live, who provide mobile merchandising and data analytics for live events. Talk data to her at zoesamuel.com and @zoe_samuel.

Lack of Diversity in Hollywood Blockbusters is “Staggering”

Examining the top 100 domestic grossing sci-fi and fantasy movies as reported by Box Office Mojo, the study finds that only 14 percent of the movies feature a female protagonist and only 8 percent feature a protagonist of color.

This is a guest post from LEE & LOW BOOKS.

As moviegoers flock to theaters this weekend to see Lucy and Guardians of the Galaxy, a new study released by children’s book publisher LEE & LOW BOOKS illuminates the dramatic lack of diversity in top-grossing Hollywood blockbusters in the science fiction and fantasy genres. Examining the top 100 domestic grossing sci-fi and fantasy movies as reported by Box Office Mojo, the study finds that only 14 percent of the movies feature a female protagonist and only 8 percent feature a protagonist of color.

 

Click for larger image.
Click for larger image.

The study also finds that no movies on the list feature a woman of color as the protagonist; lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender protagonists are likewise absent. Only one movie (Avatar) features a protagonist with a disability. Perhaps most surprising, the study reports that only two actors of color have appeared in lead roles: Will Smith, who plays six out of the eight protagonists of color, and Keanu Reeves (The Matrix Reloaded). The last protagonist of color is Aladdin, a cartoon character voiced by a white actor.

“The statistics are certainly striking, especially since sci-fi and fantasy belong to a genre that prides itself on creativity and imagination,” says Marissa Lee, co-founder of the international grassroots organization Racebending.com, which is dedicated to furthering equal opportunities in Hollywood and beyond. “Hollywood has managed to market some weird stuff, like a tentpole movie about talking teenage turtle martial artists, or cars that change into space robots. I don’t buy that when it comes to marketing diverse leads, suddenly this giant industry can’t do it.”

Imran Siddiquee, director of communications at The Representation Project, a movement that uses film and media content to expose injustices created by gender stereotypes, says Hollywood blockbusters are rarely accidental. “Just look at the top ten films in each of the last five years: nearly every single one had a budget of more than $100 million,” Siddiquee says. “Meanwhile, there hasn’t been a single film released this year starring a person of color with a budget of more than $50 million.”

 

See also: Where’s the Diversity, Hollywood? Sci-Fi and Fantasy Blockbusters Overwhelmingly White, Male at LEE & LOW Books

 


For more than 20 years, LEE & LOW BOOKS has published award-winning children’s books that are “about everyone, for everyone” (including science fiction and fantasy under the Tu Books imprint). The company is committed to fostering conversations about race, gender, and diversity in publishing and beyond. For more information, visit leeandlow.com.