Here at
Bitch Flicks, we discuss at length the
under-representation (and often problematic representation) of women in media. In 2011,
11 percent of protagonists in the top 100 domestic grossing films were female (down from 16 percent in 2002). In contrast, women make up more than
50 percent of the population in the United States.
Toronto filmmakers Ashleigh Harrington and Jeff Hammond’s
“The Girls on Film” project was inspired by an acting class the two took together. In an
interview, Harrington says that their instructor would sometimes give male parts to female acting students as an acting exercise, and they decided they wanted to do something with that concept. Hammond adds that their goal is “entertainment” and to “stir up some questions” about gender in film.
 |
| Ashleigh Harrington and Jeff Hammond, the duo behind “The Girls on Film” |
They note that it seems natural to act in and watch these ultra-masculine scenes with women playing the men’s roles (although Hammond says that while it works with women playing men’s roles, when men play feminine characters often the result is “comedy”). Of course, this reinforces the notion that female characters are often marginalized, and the masculine–the lead–is what we aspire to be.
 |
| Harrington, left, as Tyler Durden and Cat McCormick as the narrator in Fight Club |
So far, the two have produced scenes from
Fight Club, The Town, No Country for Old Men, Star Trek, Twilight and Drive. The
Fight Club (no, not
Jane Austen Fight Club) and
Drive scenes are particularly powerful in the fact that they aren’t spectacularly jarring. Instead, they seem organic, like women belong in those roles.
 |
| Laura Miyata as Anton Chigurh in No Country for Old Men |
In a
piece at
The Guardian, Mathilda Gregory favorably reviews the project and analyzes what it is that we as audiences want and need:
“‘The Girls on Film’ project also raises a more subtle point. Do we need more films about what is typically seen as ‘female’, or do we just need to relax more about which roles women can play? What is most astonishing about these gender-switched scenes is how well they work. … I quickly forget I was watching anything other than a scene from a movie.”
The fact that we can forget we’re watching “anything other than a scene from a movie” would suggest that the answer to Gregory’s question is a resounding both.
 |
| Comparisons of the originals and their remakes |
Hammond speculates what it might be like if Hollywood remade classics like
Back to the Future with a female lead. Perhaps instead of regurgitating remakes
ad nauseum, that could be one way to refresh old stories. (Ridley Scott–who
has provided audiences with noteworthy female leads–has already
said that the
Blade Runner sequel will have a female protagonist.) While the answer to our female protagonist woes certainly isn’t recycling men’s stories and casting women in historically masculine roles, “The Girls on Film” provides an interesting and meaningful perspective into what it would look like if we allowed and expected women to have leading, “powerful” roles.
The possibilities could be endless.
—
Leigh Kolb is a composition, literature and journalism instructor at a community college in rural Missouri.
