World War Z movie poster |
Written by Amanda Rodriguez
Spoiler Alert
As someone who read and enjoyed Max Brooks’ novel World War Z, I confess that I was doubtful that the film version (also entitled World War Z) could do the complex, multiple perspective, international, decade-long “oral history” justice. Turns out, I wasn’t wrong. The sociopolitical commentary alone, not to mention the strong critique of U.S isolationism, was completely lost in the film version. Though more convenient from a narrative perspective, the film loses much of the novel’s integrity with its choice to only follow the Lane family while making American Gerry Lane (played by Brad Pitt) the sole hero of the tale. The richness of the multiple nationalities, generations, genders, educational backgrounds, etc of the perspectives represented in the novel is totally lost. The comic website The Oatmeal gives us the best film/novel comparison to date:
The Oatmeal film/novel comparison hits the old nail on the head. |
The prominent female characters in World War Z, while notably few, are intriguing, as they’re simultaneously strong and compelling, but ultimately traditional in their depiction. First, we meet Karin Lane, hero Gerry Lane’s wife, portrayed by the talented Mireille Enos (best known for her leading role on the acclaimed series The Killing).
Enos’ character Karin shields her daughter as she anxiously awaits her husband’s return along with an inevitable zombie onslaught. |
*(Check out fellow Bitch Flicks writer Megan Kearn’s post on Enos’ masterful performance on the series The Killing: Why Steely Homicide Detective Sarah Linden is so Refreshing)*
Prior to New York’s zombie infestation, we meet the Lanes in all their domestic bliss. We find stay-at-home dad Gerry making pancakes, presumably designating Karin as the sole breadwinner. Later we learn that this is because his job with the United Nations was so über important and he was super über valuable but walked away from it to be with his family. This undermines the unconventionality of the couple’s marital arrangement because the “man called out of retirement for one last world-saving job” is a tired, overplayed Hollywood trope.
However, when chaos breaks loose in the city, Karin is remarkably calm and self-possessed. She is effective in a crisis, quick-thinking, solution-oriented, and follows direction well. Karin never belts out the quintessential zombie flick chick-scream despite the fact that her entire world is devolving into terrifying, incomprehensible mayhem. It’s a pleasure to see such a strong leading lady mastering her emotions, taking action, and protecting others.
On the other hand (a hand that is unfortunately much bigger than its counterpart), Karin is much in need of Gerry’s protection. After escaping the zombie outbreak in the heart of the city, Gerry and Karin along with their kids join a civilian looting of a grocery store where Karin is attacked by two men who attempt to rape her. We could’ve lived without this attempted rape, as it does nothing to complicate the plot since there are few, if any, other instances of commentary on post-apocalyptic human-on-human violence. No, this is an excuse for Gerry to save his wife and expose her as a symbol of female vulnerability that must be protected in the face of this great crisis.
It’s amazing how many scenes show the two useless daughters sleeping…still better than the ones where they’re awake and jeopardizing everyone’s safety. |
This symbolism builds as Gerry leaves behind Karin and their two irritating daughters (who cause nothing but problems) on a secure military ship while he goes off to save the world. He barters his family’s safety for his services. We watch the couple each programing their satellite phones through which they communicate while Gerry is on his mission; Karin types “GERRY,” while Gerry types “HOME.” Throughout history and especially war narratives, women, particularly wives, have been symbols for home. Men typically pine for and seek to protect these women because of the cultural continuity they embody. Women shelter and raise children, instilling in them their culture’s values while ordering the home and keeping/creating peace. Though his country and world’s infrastructure has collapsed along with any semblance of civilization as he’s known it, Gerry seeks to protect HOME as embodied by his vulnerable wife and irritating daughters. Karin houses inside her this symbol of “home” replete with its comforting memories and the subtextual notion that through her and her daughters the human race can continue via their reproductive capacities as well as the cultural legacy they can advance.
The other noteworthy primary female character is Segen, a young soldier in the Israeli military charged with protecting Gerry and spiriting him to his plane to escape as zombies infiltrate and destroy Jerusalem, the last stronghold of civilization. (I’m not even going to touch the religious implications of that one.)
Segen, charged with Gerry’s safety, winds her way through the labyrinthine city. |
Make no mistake, Segen (depicted by Daniella Kertesz), is a hardcore badass. She’s a brave soldier who does not succumb to the feverish panic that overtakes her home during the zombie attack. She skillfully wields a big-ass gun and does her duty to protect Gerry and guide him to safety. Unfortunately, Gerry ends up saving her (of course because this guy has got to save everyone, especially if there’s a vagina involved). When Segen is bitten, Gerry cuts off her hand at the wrist, saving her life. She (understandably) begins screaming uncontrollably, and he drags her onto the last plane escaping the city where he dresses her wound. To her credit, Segen never loses consciousness and bears it all without painkillers.
Gerry protects and cares for the young female soldier: the paternalistic attitude of the film on full display |
Later, she is instrumental in Gerry’s plans to thwart the spread of the virus at a research outpost of the World Health Organization, using her military skills in stealth and weaponry, but we know nothing about her. We only have the name “Segen,” with no idea if it’s her first/last name or a nickname. Though she’s a major character who survives to the end, we learn nothing of her background, who she’s lost, or even how she feels about her military conscription. I confess; I find her military conscription to be her most interesting quality. Women are required to serve in the Israeli military for at least two years, and Segen seems to embrace her role naturally, her fearlessness and aggressiveness serving her well at the end of the world. It made me curious whether or not she’d chosen to stay enlisted beyond her two years. Had she chosen the life of a career military officer? What were her hopes and dreams before the world went to shit? Apparently, it’s not important for her to be three-dimensional despite the fact that we learn much more intimate details about much more minor characters…who happen to be male.
Drawing of Segen as she scours a W.H.O facility for deadly diseases while dodging zombies. |
Though she, like the young Tomas, only lives because Gerry saved her, Segen is not enfolded into the Lane family at the film’s close. The Lanes adopt Tomas because he’s lost everything, and they feel responsible for him. Though the same is true of Gerry’s attitude toward Segen, she is not invited to join the extended post-apocalyptic family with ties that are more than blood. Perhaps it’s because the filmmakers can’t imagine Karin not being jealous of the fierce, beautiful young woman whom Gerry’s taken under his wing. Perhaps they thought it too non-traditional to have two women of sexual maturity living together because of potentially polyamorous implications. Instead, Segen just disappears. We don’t know where she goes after the film has ended much like we don’t know where she came from before the the movie began.
Though both Karin and Segen are strong, admirable women, we didn’t get to know them outside their relationship to Gerry. The film chose not to develop them as individuals separate from Gerry because they’re both designed to reflect back upon him, his intelligence, perseverance, and morality. Gerry is a messianic figure, and who are the Virgin Mary or Mary Magdalene without the narrative of Christ? They, like our two World War Z female characters, are props on our hero’s journey, illustrating more about him and his qualities than exuding any sort of well-rounded individuality. Though I’m surprised and pleased that I liked the women of World War Z (not the female children, though; them I abhorred), the film left me wishing it had bothered to develop its badass female characters.
Maybe Segen went on figting . Since it would be her duty as a soldier
The part that irked me the most about this film was Brad Pitt whining about how he had to get home to save his family because they weren’t safe. If they weren’t, I imagine it would have made a much more exciting story to actually see Mireille fighting for life and her children. Instead, it’s no surprise, they were just calmly waiting for Gerry to come get them.
Segen
Segen is in the back of the boat with Gerry in the end and she doesn’t pass out because Gerry gives her a shot of adrenaline
Why was such a homely actress cast as Brad’s wife?
Are you kidding me?? Who the hell cares what she looks like???
I agree with Megan the opioness, she isn’t homely, and what does it matter if your opinion of her looks differs from how others see her? She did a great job.
Interesting view of Segen, I’m glad that someone is talking about her because surprisingly few are…
a little more info: ‘Segen’ means 1st Lieutenant… so Segen, by insisting that is her only name, is completely committed to her service, it’s her identity and gives a view as to the psychological role in the losing of her hand / military utility… and her beginning to heal by being a key person to Gerry’s survival and success on the plane and at the WHO facility. By my count she saves Gerry’s life a minimum of 6 times…. truly a strong character… stronger than Gerry in certain dimensions. I agree that we should have had a little more about her that didn’t require knowledge about the Hebrew names of IDF ranks.
a minor error in the article: she DID have painkillers, Gerry gave her a morphine shot in the leg while the another female IDF soldier (played by Noa Bodner who got zero credit in the film) was field dressing her hand… so much more realistic
and a MAJOR error in the article that portrays the film unfairly: interestingly, she DID return with Gerry to his family… she left the WHO facility with him and you can see her in the boat when he gets back to Nova Scotia and his family. She saved his life several times and her home is gone so of course she’s going with Gerry. Also, his wife is very strong herself so I don’t really see Segen being a problem. So, I’ll respectfully disagree with that part of the article.
World War Z 2 is coming and I’m sure she will have a major role. Overall a great female character, congrats to Daniella Kertesz for playing it so well.
Gerry and Segen getting off the boat in Nova Scotia, it’s all in the family now:
Really love what you wrote
Thanks!
I agree with you only with the fact of the kids that seriously are a major pain in the ass ,but in other hand also half with the fact that Bratt has to be a Savior , Wake up woman! it’s a movie it’s all fake if it has been more realistic most of the people will consider this boring and will hate it ,there need to be a important character where he will save the lie to every one .Then Karin Bad-ass …are u fucking kidding me ..she a complete lost of time , she saved his life one time and killed almost ALL the SEALS in the Korean base ,and not talking about every fucking time she cried because the phone didn’t connect ,how the fuck did you survive all the time he was there working in his old job .Also knowing that you like insulting people I strongly respect what you say about Segen ,but for other be more informed like USAisROME
there’s a tendency on this site to extrapolate a little too far on misogynistic themes… does it happen? yeah… does it happen everywhere all the time? definitely not… to infer that Gerry’s wife is going to be a jealous pain in the ass about Segen is going way too far and it demeans women to make that assumption which is the complete opposite of this sites purpose.
.
I love very strong women and if a Segen out there wants to get married, call me… LOL…. but btchflcks needs to lay off seeing bias in everything…. by all means, call it out when you women see it, but overreaching does you a great disservice and loses your major allies, like me
Very interesting article but you are probably wrong in one point. At the end of the movie we see Segen on board of the little boat with Gerry. This keeps the question whether they stay in touch or whether she becomes part of his “family” quote open …