This is a guest post by Katie Roussos.
A rose bush inhabited by genetically modified rats who become murderous sounds more like a horror movie than a children’s story, but that is just one of the ways The Secret of N.I.H.M. breaks the mold.
The plow has come early to the Fitzgibbons farm, a frightening thought for all the animals that live in the fields. Mr. and Mrs. Fitzgibbons also happen to have a band of rats living on their farm who were part of an experiment from the National Institute of Mental Health that made them “intelligent.” As Nicodemus, head intelligent rat (who is also a little magic?) tells the audience eerily: “We found out, we could reeead.”
Besides the super rats, there are many animals, from mice, to crows, to wise old owls, and the family cat. As in most children’s films the animals can talk, can communicate across species, and have traits, clothes, and social institutions that mimic humans. It is the classic story of mouse meets mouse, mouse falls in love, gets married, builds tiny house with tiny beds and tiny tables, has children that wear gender appropriate clothing, has local shrew babysit. Yes, there is a character called Aunty Shrew, an actual shrew, and yes, she is portrayed as “shrewish”–annoying, controlling, and, mysteriously, British.
So no, the The Secret of N.I.M.H. is not free from gender stereotypes or tired portrayals of women. But The Secret of N.I.M.H. has one thing that many children’s films don’t have, a female protagonist. A main character who is a hero because of her strong will, intelligence, and heart (not accidentally a hero because of her knowledge of beauty products a la Elle Woods).
Mrs. Brisby is a single mother known only by her husband’s name in the film. And time and again that name gets her help from the other characters in the movie who remember her husband, Jonathan, fondly. However, it is not just the name that gets Mrs. Brisby’s tiny house moved out of the way of the plow and keeps her children from impeding doom. She shows fear and dread, she takes risks and shakes and cries. Yet she presses on. She is not a female hero full of bravado and stereotypically male characteristics. She is a mother who will face even a large owl (owls eat mice) to find out how to save her family.
She humbly says to the great owl, “I don’t understand what you mean, but I will do as you say.” This is not subservience–it is smarts. When a large owl who could eat you and has lived longer than your mouse body is capable of gives you advice about the farm you live on, you take it. Especially when there is no other option. Points for Mrs. Brisby for being able to take a leap of faith and admit it when she doesn’t know what to do!
Brisby also has to face an almost completely male world. Aside from the shrew and her daughters, there are no other prominent female characters. There are however many males, who do their best to either help or hurt her.
Justin is the handsome rat who, at one mention of Brisby’s dead hubby, is committed to helping her move her house to avoid the plow. Jenner is the power hungry rat who wants to take over for the aging Nicodemus, by killing him. The crow Jeremy is love sick and bumbling but tries to help her after she saves him from the family cat. (If there is any meaning behind all the “J” names I haven’t figured it out.) And then there is Mr. Ages, the only surviving mouse who has had the shot that turns animals into reading machines. He’s not the grandfatherly type, but the old cynic, who’s it-can’t-be-done attitude is a good juxtaposition for Mrs. Brisby’s heart. The movie manages to balance cute camp and is genuinely scary. (See the theatrical release poster, which is mostly just
scary…) While their mother is getting chased by a large and silent rat with a steel spear, the Brisby kids are tying up Jeremy, who was sent to babysit them, and accusing him of being a spy. A spy for what is unclear. The film ends with a love song and Jeremy finding his perfect female counterpart (blah). Even though Nicodemus is actually murdered and two other rats die in a fight after moving the Brisby home, there is a happy ending. Not too happy though. Brisby does not end up with Justin, despite the rather nauseating flirting that goes on at their first meeting.
Through it all Brisby avoids being the type of female character that make me cringe. A few more points that make her awesome:
- No fur boobs: the tendency to sexualize animals’ bodies to make them look more human might have its place in comic books (or not), but luckily the 1980s illustrators of Secret did little to feminize Mrs. Brisby. She has long lashes and a small red cape, but no busting chest, long legs, or human-shaped butt.
- She can read too!: She didn’t get experimented on and yet she can read. She was taught. Amazingly, all those male rats have used their smarts to steal electricity. Jonathan Brisby taught his wife to read. And guess what, it worked and did not require a big painful shot.
- Her ultimate goal has nothing to do with finding a husband: At no point in the film is her lack of a husband an actual hurdle. Sure, Mrs. Brisby misses Jonathan, but the film takes for granted that she is making it alone in this crazy rat-filled world. And, as I already pointed out, she doesn’t marry Justin!
I can’t deny that parts of this movie are problematic. We never even learn the main character’s name. Brisby asks Jeremy, a decided clutz to babysit because “she needs a big strong male to watch the children,” and he jumps at the chance to play “domestic.” And yet The Secret of N.I.M.H. doesn’t belong with the worst offenders in children’s movies that teach little girls early how to be less than little boys. Maybe it is because I have been watching this movie since I was four, but Mrs. Brisby inspires me. If raising a cement block out of the mud with only the power of love and a ruby necklace to save your four kids is not worthy of respect, then I don’t know what is.
—–
Katie Roussos is a labor organizer living in New York City. She graduated from the University of Massachusetts Amherst with a degree in Comparative Literature and has not stopped writing, despite the fact that she is not working in the literary field. This is her first submission to Bitch Flicks, but she is a lover of feminist blogs and hopes to submit to others in the future.
I love, love, LOVE ‘The Secret of NIMH!!’ It was my absolute favorite animated film growing up.
As a feminist vegan, I adored that a film showcased the evils of animal testing laboratories. AND with a female protagonist!
Is it problematic that Mrs. Brisby doesn’t have a first name, her identity intertwined with her husband, or that she turns to male mice & rats to save her family? Sure. But as you point out, she’s an intelligent, strong-willed, brave, single mother.
Best of all, Mrs. Brisby saves herself when she gets caged by the Fitzgibbons’ son (which differs from the book where Justin saves her…gag). SPOILER! -> Ultimately, she rescues her children and her house, with help from the mystical amulet of course, because of her courageous heart. < - END SPOILER Too many children’s (and adult’s) films focus on men or boys on a transformational quest while women and girls seek love. But at the end of Mrs. Brisby’s ordeal, she learns she is smarter and stronger than she ever realized. That’s a message more girls and women need to see.
Great post. But I’d like to add a few more points about the ways in which the Secret of NIMH departs from conventional children’s fantasy – just to really drive home it’s feminist awesomeness.
(1) A very quick opening point: unlike many other children’s movies, it is the father who is killed off screen early on.
(2) Jeremy is portrayed as a male who circumvents traditional masculine roles. Throughout the movie, all he wants to do is “settle down” and find true role – motives that are usually reserved for main female characters in films (notably, Mrs. Brisby has no such desire, as the review above pointed out). And yet, while Jeremy is seen as “silly,” he is not portrayed negatively for these “traditionally female” desires – he is a loyal and brave friend who tries to support Mrs. Brisby in whatever way he can.
(3) On another quick masculinity point – Jenner is the only named character who is shown bad-mouthing Mrs. Brisby because she is a woman, and the audience (read: children) can easily read this as being a “bad” trait coming from an antagonistic character. His masculinity, in direct contrast to Jeremy’s, is based in violence, and characterizes his villainy.
(4) Although Auntie Shrew is a disagreeable and testy (british?) woman like her stereotypical name would imply, she is nevertheless pretty kickass. Her job is not merely Mrs. Brisby’s nanny – she is in charge of alerting all the field animals to the tractor’s movements. And it was she who courageously leaps upon the tractor and burst its fuel line. She is impervious to Jeremy’s feeble attempts to appeal to her femaleness (“that’s a lovely hat you’re wearing!” just doesn’t cut it with her). And, it is Auntie Shrew who helps build up Mrs. Brisby’s courage, and encourages her to go see the great owl (i.e., two female characters working in solidarity with each to further a goal that is NOT simply getting a man).
Overall a wonderful movie, and a wonderful review. There are, of course, still some problems (i.e., the amulet severely burns Mrs. Brisby’s hands, conveying the notion that power is “injurious to women” for one example) – but the movie was lightyears ahead of it’s time in terms of feminist-friendly movies for children (and still is!).
Could you write a feminist review on shows and movies featuring a main female animal protagonist, including…
1) Chi’s Sweet Home and Chi’s New Address (anime and manga): Chi the kitten
2) Chicken Run (clay animated movie): Ginger the hen
3) Sagwa The Chinese Siamese Cat (animated TV series): Sagwa the kitten
4) Poppy Cat (children’s book and animated TV series): Poppy the cat