Leading up to the 2011 Oscars, we’ll showcase the past twenty years of Oscar Acceptance Speeches by Best Actress winners and Best Supporting Actress winners. (Note: In most cases, you’ll have to click through to YouTube in order to watch the speeches, as embedding has been disabled at the request of copyright owners.)
Best Actress Nominees: 2009
Anne Hathaway, Rachel Getting Married (read our two-part Ripley’s Pick here and here)
Angelina Jolie, Changeling
Melissa Leo, Frozen River
Meryl Streep, Doubt
Kate Winslet, The Reader
Best Supporting Actress Nominees: 2009
Amy Adams, Doubt
Penélope Cruz, Vicky Cristina Barcelona (read our Ripley’s Rebuke here)
Viola Davis, Doubt
Taraji P. Henson, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
Marisa Tomei, The Wrestler
**********
Kate Winslet wins Best Actress for her performance in The Reader.
Penélope Cruz wins Best Supporting Actress for her role in Vicky Cristina Barcelona.
**********
Unlike 2008, the right women did not win in 2009. Winslet and Cruz are fantastic, but these were not their best roles. Both, in fact, seem a lot like make-up awards–when Winslet should have won for _Revolutionary Road_ and Cruz for _Volver_.
I wrote in my review of _Vicky Cristina Barcelona_ how much I hated that shrieking cartoon of a character Cruz played, and all I can think about regarding her win in 2009 is that she was rewarded for playing a ridiculous cliche, rather than a strong and interesting woman in _Volver_. Sure, Cruz is an Oscar-caliber actress, but this certainly wasn’t the role to highlight.
Winslet could’ve won several times before _The Reader_…I’m glad she has an Oscar, but, again, this wasn’t her best role. Hathaway, Leo, and Streep were phenomenal in their nominated roles.
I never saw Vicky Cristina Barcelona (mainly because of your scathing review of it–and I TRUST YOU) … but I did see The Reader, and I thought Winslet was amazing in that role. It was a much quieter performance than her role in Revolutionary Road (with all the yelling and the crying and the running away to the woods), and it was the *subtlety* of her performance in The Reader that I found so incredible. Streep and Winslet are at the top of my list of actors who can convey volumes with a facial expression … and Winslet in The Reader pretty much devastated me.